"Is mentee a real word? I hate it" states Andy Grove, former chairman and chief executive officer of Intel recently in this article at Bloomberg Businessweek. Grove feels that managers should be acting as a mentor by being open to sharing information and learning from others everyday. Grove has a special dislike of mentoring programs constructed as stand-alone, separate programs that lead participants to feel as if mentoring is something you do part-time. "My problem is this: As a manager you are supposed to be a resource. The principal job of somebody in management is to be a resource to the people who work for you" Grove clarifies. The point is that mentoring should not be confined by the constraints of scheduled sessions and company-sanctioned forms and processes.
Another current take on mentoring is that many organizations have not brought mentoring into the current age. Mentoring is not strictly about seasoned managers taking younger, less-experienced employees under their wing. This contributes to the many myths that surround mentoring. Here, courtesy of Amy Gallo, contributing editor at Harvard Business Review in her article Demystifying Mentoring is a list of common mentoring myths:
- You have to find one perfect mentor
- Mentoring is a formal long-term relationship
- Mentoring is for junior people
- Mentoring is something more experienced people do out of the goodness of their hearts
Check out both articles and think about your organization's mentoring plan. Maybe it's time to update it, bring it in line with current business needs, and ensure mentoring is less a program and more a integrated part of company culture.
I leave you, my fellow human resource practitioners, with a final quote from Grove (you'll love this): "I suspect the reason these programs exist is so HR can beat you up and have something they can brag about". Oh boy...